The Washington Square West Historic District, encompassing 1,441 properties in Center City, was recently overturned by Civil Court Judge Christopher Hall. Established in 2024, this historic district was Philadelphia’s largest, featuring buildings from 1740 to 1985 and supported by the Preservation Alliance and local civic groups. Opponents, led by residents Jonathan Hesney, Colin Murphy, and Joshua Zagerman, argued that the restrictions would raise costs for property owners. Their attorney, Dan Auerbach, criticized the historical commission’s process, stating it lacked substantial evidence to prove the area’s historical significance. Hall agreed, noting the nomination violated the city’s ethics rules. He expressed skepticism about the support presented during hearings, labeling them as conclusions without factual backing.
Emily Cooperman, a historical commission member involved in the nomination, defended her actions as compliant with ethical guidelines, claiming she recused herself during the voting. In Hall’s brief ruling, he emphasized that the nomination lacked sufficient evidence, prompting city officials to review options following the decision. Auerbach remarked that this case highlights the need for preservationists to provide solid evidence in future nominations. The ruling stands among other recent legal challenges against historic district designations in Philadelphia, which typically favor the historical commission’s expertise.
Source link
