The Supreme Court recently grappled with cases regarding property rights and the government’s ability to collect unpaid taxes, specifically whether counties can foreclose on homes for unpaid taxes and sell them at auction for less than the homeowners could have received. In a 2023 ruling, the Court established that governments must return any auction proceeds exceeding the taxes owed.
In a case from Michigan involving Timothy Pun’s estate, the family argued they were entitled to the property’s fair market value of $194,000 instead of just the taxes owed. The property was sold for $76,000, leading to a legal dispute about the fairness of the foreclosure sale process.
The justices had mixed sentiments. Some, like Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, questioned the fairness of the auction process, suggesting homeowners could have sold their property themselves to capture its true value. Others, including Justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor, raised concerns about potential injustices in the proceedings.
The argument was further complicated by the potential implications of requiring governments to pay more than they collect from such sales, which could strain finances and impact other taxpayers adversely. A ruling on the case is anticipated by summer.
Source link
