The New York Federal Court of Appeals has ordered a new trial or release for Pedro Hernandez, a former bodega clerk convicted of the 1979 murder of 6-year-old Etan Patz. Hernandez, 64, was found guilty in 2017 after confessing to luring Patz into a basement under false pretenses. He received a 25-to-life sentence linked to a case that has haunted New York City since Patz’s disappearance prompted a national campaign to find missing children.
On Monday, a three-judge panel issued a 51-page ruling, determining that erroneous jury instructions regarding Hernandez’s confession affected the trial’s outcome. His lawyers argued that Hernandez’s mental illness and the circumstances surrounding his confession—made after extensive police questioning without proper advisement of his rights—contaminated the verdict.
The panel emphasized that the error was not harmless and highlighted flaws in how the confession was handled during the trial. Following the ruling, the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office indicated they are reviewing the decision. Hernandez’s legal team expressed gratitude for the court’s decision, asserting he has been wrongfully imprisoned for over 13 years.
The case has a long history; Etan went missing on May 25, 1979, while walking to a bus stop near his home, and he was later declared dead in 2001. Hernandez confessed in 2012 based on a tip from a family member but offered no clear motive for the crime. His original trial faced lengthy juror deliberation, with mixed views on the validity of his confession. The recent court ruling gives Hernandez the opportunity to reclaim his life, prompting calls for the charges against him to be dropped.
Source link
